PROGRESS REPORT #2
1. INTRODUCTION
This report summarizes the current progress of the Attitude
Determination and Control (ADC) Division of the Acme Aerospace Company
for February 11-17, 1998. This report will describe the different options
of ADC, as well as make preliminary suggestions as to which are more
applicable to the Odysseus missions.
2. PROGRESS
2.1 Sources of Attitude Disturbances
The attitude of a spacecraft, or its orientation, is
determined by position, velocity, attitude and attitude motion. The
initial two parameters are translational parameters, and are not dealt
with under the topic of Attitude Determination and Control. The latter
two are rotational parameters which must be determined and controlled by
the ADC instrumentation. Instrumentation for ADC usually involves major
subsystems of the vehicle. They are often massive, power consuming and
have stringent orientation demands.
A spacecraft is in a relatively low torque environment, however
the absence of other disturbances, slight torques from different sources
can greatly affect the vehicles attitude. The main sources of torque are
:
- Aerodynamic torque : arises in vehicles in low earth orbit from the
satellite drag, producing a torque due to the offset of the center of
gravity and the aerodynamic center of pressure. The magnitude of this
effect varies widely in the upper atmosphere as the density can vary
greatly from standard models. Left uncorrected the atmospheric drag
grows quadratically with time. Fortunately, this drag is only a factor at
altitudes less than 500 km.
- Magnetic field of the Earth (or other large body) : arises in low
orbits around planets with substantial magnetic fields such as the Earth
and Jupiter. It is not yet certain whether Mars has a strong enough
magnetic field to exert this torque on the orbiting craft. The torque
arises from the interaction of the magnetic fields of the spacecraft and
the planet. It is a factor at altitudes between 500 and 35,000 km.
- Gravity Gradient : arises from the small difference in the
gravitational force between its "lower" and "upper"
sides. This causes the body to rotate until its longest axis, the axis
with the minimum inertia, points toward the planet. This torque is also
a factor between 550- 35,00 km.
- Solar Radiation : arises from both electro-magnetic radiation and
particles radiating from the Sun. This is the only torque which is
present during interplanetary flight. It is negligible when in close
proximity to a planet or large body.
2.2 Methods of Attitude Control
Since torques exist throughout the entire environment of the
mission, some method of attitude control is required. This can come in
several forms.
- The spacecrafts own angular momentum
- In this situation, the vehicle is "spin stabilized" by
spinning the spacecraft. In inertial space, the angular momentum of a
spinning object will remain fixed for extended periods of time with
little or no external torques. If disturbed, a spinning body will return
to its stable position.
- This method is very simple and reliable. Long-term stability, such as
is needed for an interplanetary mission, requires pure spin around the
satellites major axis, that with the most inertia. Therefore, for spin
stabilized spacecraft, a wheel shape is desired over a pencil shape.
- A problem with spin stabilization is that it is difficult to keep
tele-communications and other directional instrumentation pointed in a
specific direction (i.e. at the Earth.)
- Spin stabilization may be a good choice for the Odysseus I, providing
that the instrumentation aboard is compatible with a rotating vehicle.
- The spacecrafts response to environmental torques
- In this case, the body aligns itself in a stable manner according to
the environmental torque. For example, in the presence of
gravity-gradient torque, if the minor axis is pointed toward the planet.
- These environmental torques (except solar radiation) are only present
near planets and might be useful in orbits around Earth and Mars.
- Active control (for spacecraft which are "Three-Axes
Stabilized," having all axis fixed in inertial space)
- Reaction Wheels : consist of a flywheel rigidly mounted to the
vehicle. Using a motor to rotate the wheel will generate an opposite
rotation in the spacecraft in order to conserve angular momentum. Since
the inertia of the spacecraft is much greater than that of the wheel, the
wheel will spin much faster than the vehicle. This make the wheel able
to react to very sensitive variations in the vehicles attitude. Three
such wheels are required in order to control all the possible directions
of torque, with at least one more provided for redundancy.
- Reaction wheels are weighty, expensive and have fast moving parts
subject to wear and malfunctions.
- They respond quickly relative to other systems.
- The reaction wheel can only store, not remove momentum. Therefore,
in order to compensate for a continual torque, the wheel must spin faster
and faster. When the wheel reaches the fastest speed of the motor, it
becomes saturated. At this point, some secondary system, such as jets,
must be utilized to hold the vehicle steady while the wheels wind down,
called "momentum dumping."
- Control Moment Gyros : use another configuration of reaction wheels.
These are mounted with gimbals and is constantly spinning. Adjusting the
direction of the gyro will alter the direction of the spacecraft.
- Gyros are very heavy, but provide greater accuracy than flywheels.
- Gyros also involve momentum dumping.
- Each can control the motion around 2 perpendicular axes, so three
gyros can exert complete redundancy over all three axes.
- The greater power of each gyroscope makes them a good possibility for
use in the Odysseus II. Reaction time is on the order of that of
reaction jets.
- Reaction Jets : common and effective ways of inducing a torque on the
vehicle. Two opposing jets, centered around the CG can create a torque
with out creating a translational disturbance.
- Standard on manned spacecraft because they can quickly exert large
forces.
- They use consumable fuel and need redundant systems which become
heavy and complex.
- Can perturb orbit if the two opposing jets are not precisely centered
around the CG.
- Will be necessary for momentum dumping if reaction wheels or
gyroscopic control is used in the Odysseus II, although they probably use
too much fuel to be the primary source of attitude control on an
interplanetary mission.
2.3 Methods of Attitude Determination
In order to detect the deviation of the attitude from the expected
value, measurement of the divergence must be made. There are several
different ways of doing so.
- Spin Stabilized Spacecraft
- Sun Sensors : uses a narrow slit and a photosensitive sensor to
measure the angle between the sun and the spin axis of the vehicle, the
Sun angle, b
.
- Earth horizon telescope : has a narrow field of view which sweeps out
a cone, overlapping the horizon of the earth. Sensing the reflected
light from the planet, the sensor produces a pulse. Another pulse is
generated when the telescope crosses back off the earth and into dark
space. The time between these pulses, the spin frequency of the
spacecraft and the known size of the earth allow the attitude of the
vehicle to be calculated.
- This is only available in orbit around the Earth.
- Relies on the rotation of the vehicle.
- Three-Axis Stabilized Spacecraft
- Two Axis Sun Sensor : use two sun sensors to locate the direction of
the sun. Needs another reference point to fix the rotation of the
vehicle around the suns vector. The other vector can be a measurement of
the magnetic field of the Earth. This is only available in Earth
orbits.
- Star Sensors : Very accurately measure the direction of stars with
respect to body frame of reference.
- Independent of orbit.
- Complex and heavy. Usually use different attitude determination
method for an initial estimate and only refine measurements.
- Gyroscopes : measure incremental changes in attitude, but require
another system (i.e. star sensors) to provide absolute measurements.
Therefore, the initial research points to a more wheel-like, spin
stabilized structure for the Odysseus I. Due to the further
complications of the manned nature of the Odysseus II, the structure will
probably be three-axis stabilized with gyroscopes and reaction jets for
attitude control. Attitude determination will likely be a combination of
gyroscopic response and star sensors or sun sensors.
3. Remaining Work
The next step in design of the missions ADC is to further
refine the instrumentation which is to be used for both Odysseus I and
II. After a flight trajectory is mapped out, including the parking orbit
altitudes at both Earth and Mars, the influence of different
environmental torques will be calculated. Also, the refinement of the
type of attitude determination devices to